It’s a tale as old as time, or at least Patrick Mahomes’ career; the Kansas City Chiefs have won without quality wide receiver play. That’s certainly been the case for most of this season; Kansas City is 7-2 despite the fact that no wideout has more than 374 receiving yards, the sixth-lowest total of any team-leading wide receiver.
Now, the team’s fortunes at the position seem to be turning around. The Chiefs invested heavily at the trade deadline, sending a fourth-round pick and a fifth-round pick to the Indianapolis Colts for wideout Josh Downs and a seventh-round pick, and he made his debut in Week 10 to help unlock Kansas City’s offense.
Downs’ arrival could be problematic for current WR1 Rashee Rice, who has been among the most frequently-traded receivers today in Yahoo Sports fantasy leagues.
Results and Usage
Rice has missed two games and most of a third due to injury, but when he’s played, he’s been solid, recording at least 80 yards on three different occasions and managing at least 13 DraftKings DFS points thrice. He was still the team’s leading receiver in the Week 10 win against the Atlanta Falcons, recording six targets (second to only running back Emmett Johnson) and turning them into a team-best 82 yards. Downs, meanwhile, chipped in with four catches from five targets for 53 yards and a score (a season-high 15.3 DraftKings DFS points).
So far, Rice has still graded out as the most talented receiver on the roster. He ranks 32nd among 122 qualified wideouts by Pro Football Focus’ offensive grades, while Downs ranks 38th and the injured Tyquan Thornton, who could return for the postseason after dislocating his ankle in Week 4, slots in at 37th. Rice has also been better than Downs after the catch, gaining 0.9 yards per reception over expectation after the catch, while Downs has gained 0.5, and he’s produced more separation per average targeted route. Still, Downs is a solid addition, totaling 33 catches for 354 yards and a score in Indianapolis despite playing with a woeful signal-caller in Daniel Jones.
Future Outlook
The biggest cause for concern for Rice’s fantasy outlook in Week 11 isn’t his target share, since that’s still higher than Downs’. In that game, he only appeared in 46% of the team’s offensive snaps, his lowest mark of the season (excepting Week 4, when he left early with an injury). Instead, Xavier Worthy proved himself to be the de facto WR1, appearing in 87.7% of the team’s snaps, even though he garnered only three targets and failed to catch any of them. Downs played even fewer snaps (just 17% of the team’s total), but the Chiefs’ offense could be especially run-centric in Week 11 if both Kenneth Walker III and Emmett Johnson end up playing, and Downs is the significantly better run-blocker.
I’m not overly concerned about Rice, given that Downs isn’t a high-volume receiver. In his first four seasons, Rice has averaged 5.3 receptions per game, and Downs has never had a season in which he managed more than 5.1. In fact, Downs has only had two games this season in which he’s even caught five passes, including none since Week 4, and it’s not like the Colts had a stacked receiving corps for him to compete with. Downs has played a majority of his snaps in the slot and Rice a majority of his on the outside, and Downs has operated primarily as a deep threat this season while Rice is a short-yardage possession receiver. Both players’ ceiling will likely be limited somewhat by the Walker-Johnson running back duo, but I expect Downs to take more targets from Worthy in the long run.
Rice is still worth starting this weekend against the Arizona Cardinals, who don’t have a very good defense. This season, Arizona has allowed the 16th-most FPTS per game to wide receivers, conceding the 11th-most yards and the third-most touchdowns. In particular, opponents have been ruthlessly efficient against the Cardinals, managing the seventh-most yards after the catch, where Rice has thrived. Arizona ranks dead last by expected points added on passing plays, giving up the highest passer rating. The Cardinals have been porous enough defensively that there’s a world in which all four of Walker, Johnson, Downs, and Rice are fantasy-viable.