Indianapolis Colts running back Jonathan Taylor was one of the biggest names running through the NFL rumor mill before the Trade Deadline. Ultimately, though, the Colts opted to keep the superstar running back, and they reportedly view him as a key part of their future. Taylor has been sharing time for the last few weeks with rookie Seth McGowan, but how concerned should Taylor’s fantasy managers be over his potential loss of some work? Will Taylor still be a regular starting option for the rebuilding Colts the rest of the season?
Let’s look at Taylor’s season so far and what to expect from him moving forward.
Jonathan Taylor – 2026 Overview
The Colts have struggled to a 3-7 record, but Taylor has still been very solid. He has been the No. 8 RB in raw PPR scoring this season and the No. 11 RB in average PPR fantasy points per game. He has 739 rushing yards on 177 carries, while adding 28 catches for 240 receiving yards. He has eight touchdowns in 10 games and has produced double-digit FPTS in eight of his 10 contests.
His best fantasy game of the year was in Week 2 against the Chiefs, when he had two rushing touchdowns, 92 rushing yards, and 40 receiving yards. As the Trade Deadline approached, it seemed that the team was managing his workload more carefully, as he had just eight carries in Week 8 and 13 carries in Week 9.
When the team has had success on offense, it has been largely by relying on Taylor as one of the focal points of the offense since Daniel Jones has struggled, throwing just seven touchdowns and 12 interceptions in 10 games. Jones has only averaged 183 passing yards per game and hasn’t thrown multiple touchdowns in any contest, which has limited the upside of the offense overall.
Taylor’s production, despite the team’s struggles, has been impressive, but can he keep things rolling going forward?
Jonathan Taylor Fantasy Football Outlook
The Colts have given rookie Seth McGowan more work in the last few weeks. He had his first career touchdown in Week 9, and a career-high 12 carries for 77 yards and another score in Week 10. Especially in a week with so many teams on a bye, McGowan is a FLEX consideration in Week 11 against the Texans. What does that mean for Taylor, though?
The good news for Taylor managers is that his snap share has actually only dropped a little bit. He played 69% of snaps in Week 9 and 68% of snaps in Week 10. Now that the trade possibility is no longer on the table, the team will likely go back to him as the primary workhorse in the offense and rotate in McGowan as an effective complementary role.
Taylor is also much more involved as a receiver out of the backfield, which helps maintain his value in PPR leagues. The Colts could eventually opt to go with Anthony Richardson at QB, but it’s hard to imagine the offense being less dynamic at that point. Taylor should be a solid top-15 starter every week aside from his bye week, even though McGowan will have a chance to work in as well.
The Bottom Line: Jonathan Taylor Remains a Top Running Back to Start
As long as he stays healthy, Taylor is a stud to continue to count on for the rest of the season. He does have a few tough matchups and a Week 13 bye, but he finishes the year with more favorable matchups against the Titans, Bengals and Browns from Weeks 15 through 17, when most leagues are having their playoffs.
He isn’t on the main slate this week since he and the Colts face the Texans on Thursday night. He is a high-priced, high-upside play in single-game Showdown contests like the NFL Showdown $1.11M Thursday Night Showdown [$250K to 1st] (IND @ HOU), where he is the most expensive player on the slate.