A bad week went to worse for the New England Patriots last Sunday, as quarterback Drake Maye went down with an ankle injury after being tackled by Lions defensive end Aidan Hutchinson. Further testing confirmed that the 2025 MVP runner-up suffered a fractured ankle, confirming their worst fears. What does this mean for the rest of the Patriots offense in fantasy football for the rest of the season? Let’s break it down.
Injury Outlook
Based on how the Patriots are talking about this injury, it sure doesn’t seem like we’ll see Drake Maye again this season. Head coach Mike Vrabel confirmed the ankle fracture and that Maye would be unavailable out of the bye week.
Surgery seems awfully likely for an injury of that severity, but even if he can avoid an operation, it’s a long road ahead. The average recovery time for an NFL player with a fractured ankle without surgery is 75 days; the regular season will be over well before then. It’s highly unlikely that the 5-5 Patriots will be in a position to rush him back for the playoffs.
So, we have to assume that Maye is done for the remainder of the fantasy football season. What is this going to mean for the Patriots’ fantasy football outlook?
Rest-of-Season Team Outlook
Maye’s injury isn’t the only big talking point for the Patriots. AJ Brown, who has dealt with knee and ankle injuries this year, now has a hamstring injury to add to his list of woes. That was only his fourth game of his debut season with the Patriots, and he’s likely to miss time going forward. Starting running back Rhamondre Stevenson continues to deal with a knee tendon injury and gained only five yards from scrimmage against the Lions. So, what is left of this offense?
Barring an unforeseen signing, the Patriots will be rolling with backup quarterback Tommy DeVito. After replacing Maye on Sunday, DeVito completed 12 of 24 passes for 81 yards (3.4 yards per attempt) with one touchdown and one interception. It was hardly an inspired performance, especially with the pass-friendly game script. Most of DeVito’s experience comes from 2023 with the Giants, when he made six starts in place of Daniel Jones. DeVito completed 64% of his passes and posted a 7:1 TD:INT ratio in those six starts, but threw for just 152.2 yards per game. As far as waiver wire QB options go, DeVito is among the worst, and I wouldn’t add him unless truly desperate in a two-QB league. Rookie Behren Morton figures to serve as the backup coming out of the bye.
New England’s receiver room is expected to rotate among Demario “Pop” Douglas, Mack Hollins, Kyle Williams, and Efton Chism III. Hunter Henry and Eli Raridon will also get significant usage at tight end. If healthy, Rhamondre Stevenson will lead the backfield, but Corey Kiner could work into the picture as well. With TreVeyon Henderson away, Lan Larison is on the radar for touches.
Frankly, I’m ready to throw this whole passing offense out the window. None of their four healthy receivers have shown much consistency, and I don’t trust they have a quarterback who can move the ball. We’ll know early; if DeVito can’t get it moving against the Chargers in Week 12, he won’t fare much better facing the Bills, Vikings, Chiefs, Jets and Broncos down the stretch. Romeo Doubs could return from IR and become a WR1, but his return is no guarantee.
Rhamondre Stevenson is the only player who can keep his value alive for the remainder of the fantasy season. Hopefully, a bye week is enough to heal his knee, and he should see plenty of work against the Chargers and Bills, who are struggling mightily to defend the run. His involvement in the passing game keeps him as a FLEX option in PPR leagues. But I can’t imagine Kiner or Larison having value if Stevenson is out.
Tough news is the hardest news, but here it is: if you own any Patriots players in fantasy other than Stevenson, they are expendable. It’s best to work the waiver wire instead of trying to get value from their pass catchers or backup running backs.