What a week for the San Francisco 49ers. They added Keenan Allen to their ailing wide receiver room ahead of a big road game in Dallas. It turns out Allen will debut in a historic game. The 49ers, no slouches historically, piled up 584 yards; that’s the highest mark in San Francisco’s history for a road game. In their 46-40 win over the Cowboys, everybody ate, including Allen. Does that make him a waiver wire priority heading into Week 11?
Week 10 Production
For a team debut on a short week, Keenan Allen sure found a way to make an impact. Given San Francisco’s struggles to stay healthy at wide receiver, it was unclear how high Allen would be on the totem pole from the get-go. The answer was pretty darn high.
He certainly wasn’t the headliner on the day. Christian McCaffrey had receiving touchdowns of 66 and 74 yards, George Kittle was the top target in the passing game, and Deebo Samuel turned heads with multiple touchdowns. But Allen was arguably the most impressive down-to-down presence, consistently moving the chains and forming instant chemistry with Niners quarterback Brock Purdy. If you took the stab on Allen as a flex option in PPR formats, his 5/61/0 line certainly delivered.
Rest-of-Season Outlook
But we do have to pump the brakes on Keenan Allen here. First things first: this receiver room’s health. Deebo Samuel is back in the fold and clearly involved, getting six touches on Sunday in his first game back from a three-week absence. Mike Evans is likely to return from his injury this Sunday against the Vikings; worst-case scenario, he returns Week 12 against the Seahawks. San Francisco is also expected to get rookie De’Zhaun Stribling back sometime in the next few weeks. It’s possible that by the time the fantasy playoffs roll around, the Niners can roll out Evans, Samuel, Stribling, and Allen, with a smattering of Jordan Watkins, DeMarcus Robinson, and Brandin Cooks. With Kittle and CMC as fixtures in the passing game, it’s suddenly a lot of mouths to feed.
The schedule also merits a lot of consideration here. This Sunday, the Niners play the Vikings, who have the fourth-best defense against opposing receivers in terms of fantasy points allowed. After that, it’s the Seahawks, who have the league’s best defense. Week 13 against the Giants (14th) is a reprieve before their rematch with the Rams, who are 10th. To make matters worse, Week 16 pits Allen and the Niners against the Chiefs, who have the second-best defense. Assuming you have seven weeks left on your fantasy schedule, three of those matchups are against top-four units, and five of the seven are in the top 14. Not great.
Now, that was a big bucket of cold water, but no fantasy situation is perfect. If it was, Allen wouldn’t be available anywhere. But who wins here, the pros or the cons?
Fantasy Verdict
I’d walk, but not run, to get Allen off the waiver wire. There’s a solid chance he becomes a depth piece for a team with a tough schedule in the next few weeks, and if you need someone capable of FLEX consideration for the rest of the fantasy football regular season, Allen is a shaky proposition. Definitely worth a claim or a good FAAB amount, but I wouldn’t break the bank.
The upside case is much better if your team is a lock for the postseason. Allen faces the Chargers in Week 15, typically the first week of the fantasy playoffs. They’ve been horrendous against the pass. The semifinals (Week 16) against the Chiefs aren’t as appealing, but then you have a championship-week showdown with the collapsing Eagles, another tremendously bad pass defense. If Allen has a consistent role in his offense in those two matchups, he’s well worth a FLEX stab and could be a monster if they deal with further injuries to their pass catchers.
In short, don’t go running for Allen to try and save your season in the next few weeks. But if the postseason is in your future, he’s a top option to grab.