It’s a bit of an understatement to say this is a lost season for the Indianapolis Colts. Barely squeaking by the Dolphins after a solid sell-off before the trade deadline has the vibes in the toilet. But at least rookie running back Seth McGowan has been a positive. The seventh-round pick has very much looked like a strong backup for star bell cow Jonathan Taylor. After a couple of strong performances, is he worth considering as a fantasy football waiver add?
Recent Production
It’s no hyperbole to say Week 10 was the best week of Seth McGowan’s career. The rookie out of Oklahoma set career highs in rushing attempts (12) and rushing yards (77) and scored for the second straight week. His impressive between-the-tackles running culminated in a huge run just before halftime to set up a Colts score.
It’s a continuation of the upward rise of McGowan over recent weeks. It’s his second game with 12+ touches in four weeks, after having zero in the first six weeks. He has rewarded the coaching staff’s trust, averaging 5.2 yards per carry this season. But Taylor isn’t going anywhere, and neither is his workload, leaving us in a tricky spot for evaluating his fantasy viability.
Rest-of-Season Outlook
Recent weeks have been a bit deceptive. This is McGowan’s second straight week with 10+ points in all fantasy formats, but it’s come against the Dolphins and the Cowboys; not exactly premier defenses. That’s no coincidence. In a struggling offense as the No. 2 running back, it’s hard to consistently carve out fantasy value, especially with the lack of receiving work; McGowan has only five catches for nine yards on the season.
So the fantasy bet here is for handcuff value. If anything were to knock Taylor out of the lineup, it’s clear who stands to benefit most. And this is where the schedule bears watching. After Thursday’s game against the Texans, where Taylor will play, the Colts have five matchups left on the fantasy schedule, including a bye week. All five matchups are against defenses in the top half of total defense against opposing running backs. If McGowan becomes the starter, there will be tough sledding ahead.
So, the risks are quite clear for the rookie. Is the upside worth the add?
Fantasy Verdict
In short, he is, but don’t expect this to be some massive windfall. Taylor is an absolute workhorse who stays very healthy for a running back with this kind of load. McGowan will get some quality scraps, but not enough to provide FLEX value week to week. And on the off-chance Taylor is out of the lineup, McGowan is in a bad offense facing a tough schedule. That may provide enough volume for FLEX or low-end RB2 value, but he won’t be a league-winning late-season waiver add. If you are keen on dropping someone, McGowan is worth the add, but don’t burn your top waiver claim or FAAB budget on him.