So far, this season hasn’t gone exactly as planned for either the Indianapolis Colts or the Houston Texans. The Colts looked like contenders prior to their bye last season, but they won just two of their first nine games in 2026 and sent away most of their valuable players at the trade deadline. Meanwhile, the Texans ended the 2025 season on a nine-game winning streak before ultimately falling in the Divisional Round, but they’re just 3-6.
At the start of the season, tonight’s 8:15 p.m. ET Thursday Night Football matchup might’ve seemed like a marquee showdown with major playoff implications, but circumstances change.
Houston is a 12.5-point favorite at DraftKings Sportsbook, with the point total set to 43.5. The Texans are -740 on the Moneyline, and Indianapolis is +527.
DraftKings is offering a Showdown contest for tonight’s big game with $1.11 million in prizes. Picking the right mix of studs and value options is important for winning the top prize, so in order to make a player like Jonathan Taylor ($15,900 CP) a Captain Pick, picking the right value options to supplement him is important. Here are two options I like:
Set your DraftKings fantasy football lineups here: NFL Showdown $1.11M Thursday Night Showdown [$250K to 1st] (IND @ HOU)
K Ka’imi Fairbairn, Houston Texans ($5,400)
I don’t love any of the offensive options around this price point, so instead, I’ll show some respect to one of the best and most consistent kickers in the league. Fairbairn, the fourth-most accurate kicker in NFL history, has made 19 of his 20 field goals this season and has recorded at least 11 FPTS in five of his last six games. In fact, Fairbairn has averaged the sixth-most FPTS per game of any player on the slate despite having just the 18th-highest DFS salary, and in general, Houston’s offense is starting to click more, scoring at least 24 points in five of its last six games.
The Colts have allowed the fourth-most FPTS per game to opposing kickers because their defense has been generally terrible. This season, Indianapolis has given up the fourth-most points, the fifth-most made extra points, and the third-most made field goals, and it’s arguably gotten lucky not to have allowed even more points, given that opposing kickers have made their kicks at the 12th-lowest rate. The Colts have done a respectable job in the red zone, allowing drives inside their 20 to turn into touchdowns at just the 16th-highest rate, so if the Texans don’t score, Fairbairn should have an easy opportunity to clean up. Field goals (worth three, four, or five FPTS depending on the distance) are much more valuable than extra points (one FPT).
WR Laquon Treadwell, Indianapolis Colts ($4,000)
Indianapolis finally traded away Josh Downs and Keenan Allen at the trade deadline, and with Alec Pierce ($8,000) on Injured Reserve, the Colts are extremely thin at wide receiver. Tight end Tyler Warren ($8,400) will probably get plenty of attention, but Treadwell has just 37 fewer receiving yards this season than Warren does, and he repaid Shane Steichen’s faith by hauling in all three of his targets for 24 yards and a touchdown (11.4 FPTS) in the Colts’ win over the Miami Dolphins. Most promisingly, Treadwell was on the field for 88% of Indianapolis’ offensive snaps against Miami, more than any player besides the offensive linemen and Jones, and he was the target of Jones’ only pass inside the red zone.
Treadwell has a solid matchup against a a Houston defense that has stunningly struggled this season. Despite rostering plenty of playmakers, including All-Pro edge rusher Will Anderson Jr. and a pair of elite corners in Derek Stingley Jr. and Kamari Lassiter, the Texans have allowed the third-most FPTS per game to opposing wideouts. In particular, Houston has allowed opposing passers to be pretty efficient, giving up 11.7 yards per catch, and Treadwell has been predominantly used as a deep threat this season. Lassiter has allowed nearly a 100 passer rating while in coverage this season, and while Stingley has been somewhat better, he’s given up two scores. Plus, Danielle Hunter has been ruled out for tonight’s game with a hamstring injury, so Houston likely won’t get as much pressure.
- Seth McGowan Fantasy Football Start or Sit Advice for Week 11
- Colts at Texans NFL Player Prop Bets and Picks for Thursday Night Football
- NFL RB Touch Projections — Week 11 TNF: Indianapolis Colts at Houston Texans
- David Montgomery Fantasy Football Start or Sit Advice for Week 11
- Houston Texans vs. Indianapolis Colts prediction, pick for NFL Week 11 on Thursday 11/19/26