Seth McGowan Start or Sit Advice for Week 11
The Indianapolis Colts found themselves as the ultimate sellers before the trade deadline, which came as somewhat of a surprise given that Indianapolis got off to an 8-2 start last season before suffering seven defeats in a row to end its campaign. Once the Colts decided to sell, it became even more stunning that Indianapolis opted to hold onto arguably its best player, All-Pro running back Jonathan Taylor, given the haul that some teams offered for the 27-year-old’s services. Indianapolis reportedly turned down offers that included a second-round pick.
Instead, Taylor remains on the roster alongside rookie Seth McGowan, who has been impressive this season, turning 55 carries into 285 yards and two touchdowns. As a 25-year-old who spent two seasons out of football after a 2021 arrest and three seasons at three different colleges across two levels thereafter, McGowan doesn’t fit the timeline of a rebuild significantly more than Taylor does, but he has less wear and tear on his body, and he’s been productive.
Productive doesn’t necessarily mean fantasy-viable, though. McGowan’s output across the last two weeks have given him fringe viability, as he’s scored a touchdown in each contest and managed 13.7 DraftKings DFS points in the Week 11 win against the Miami Dolphins, but he has yet to appear in even one-third of the Colts’ offensive snaps in any game. Taylor’s snap share has dipped slightly, as he played 81.2% of Indianapolis’ snaps in the first six weeks of the season and only 66.5% across the last four weeks, but those snaps haven’t solely gone to McGowan. Instead, Colts head coach Shane Steichen has opted for empty-backfield looks on occasion.
McGowan doesn’t offer a ton as a receiver, limiting his fantasy value. Although he ranks a respectable 25th among 59 qualified running backs by Pro Football Focus’ offensive grades, he has the 14th-best rushing grades and the 11th-worst receiving grades, and he’s only caught five passes for nine yards all season. He does rank fifth in yards over expectation per attempt, ahead of Taylor, but Taylor has been efficient enough that there isn’t much of a reason to give a heavy load to a player who can’t catch and can’t block, even though he’s been a better runner by some metrics.
I’d sit McGowan on Thursday Night Football against the Houston Texans. Even though Houston hasn’t been as good defensively as it was last season, when it rode its dominant defense to the Divisional Round of the playoffs, its run defense has been less problematic than its pass defense. This season, the Texans have allowed the third-most FPTS per game to opposing wide receivers, but they’ve held running backs to just the 15th-most FPTS per game. Houston has also allowed the 11th-fewest rushing yards per game, leaving McGowan’s production heavily dependent on scoring a touchdown, and Taylor has accounted for more than two-thirds of Indianapolis’c carries inside the red zone.
Start or Sit: Sit Seth McGowan.
- Colts at Texans NFL Player Prop Bets and Picks for Thursday Night Football
- NFL RB Touch Projections — Week 11 TNF: Indianapolis Colts at Houston Texans
- David Montgomery Fantasy Football Start or Sit Advice for Week 11
- Colts vs. Texans NFL DFS Value Picks for Thursday Night Football
- Houston Texans vs. Indianapolis Colts prediction, pick for NFL Week 11 on Thursday 11/19/26