Some primetime NFL games are remembered forever. However, I feel confident in saying that this will not be one of those games.
The 3-7 Colts will travel to Houston on Thursday to take on the 3-6 Texans, who might’ve just seen any slim playoff hopes they had go down the drain in a 27-24 loss to the Browns in Week 10. It’s ironic that the schedule makers spiritually managed to give us the classic Jaguars/Titans TNF battle without involving either of those organizations. To paraphrase Jeff Goldblum in Jurassic Park, the AFC South finds a way.
Let’s break down the first touchdown market on DraftKings Sportsbook for this forgettable divisional battle. Let’s also make a couple picks.
Colts vs. Texans First Touchdown Scorer Odds

Colts vs. Texans First Touchdown Scorer Picks
David Montgomery First TD Scorer (+475)
You don’t have to overthink this one too much. Was David Montgomery good prior to his injury? Not even a little bit. In fact, Montgomery’s 2.7 yards per rushing attempt and 40.4% rushing success rate were easily career-lows. That said, Montgomery is a proven goal line threat, and in Week 1, one of the few times this season the Texans’ offense has looked decent with Montgomery active, the veteran RB scored three touchdowns — including the game’s first. Houston is averaging 30.8 points per contest since the beginning of Week 6, and I don’t think they’re going to be slowed down by a Colts defense that’s been thinned by injury and trades. Montgomery is going to get ample opportunity to do what he does best: Find the end zone in short-yardage situations.
Seth McGowan First TD Scorer (+1800)
I’ll admit, McGowan’s 28.8% snap share from last week’s win over the Dolphins doesn’t match the impact it felt he was having on the game. Still, that might be because touched the ball 12 times on his 17 offensive plays. It might also be because McGowan averaged more yards per carry than Jonathan Taylor (+800) and had as many red zone rushing attempts (2). Heck, the rookie literally scored that game’s first touchdown. There’s a blueprint here. Many assumed Taylor would revert back to his usual monopoly on Indianapolis’ backfield workload with the trade deadline in the rearview, but that simply was not the case. In fact, over their last three contests, Taylor’s 152 rushing yards only juuuuuust outpace McGowan (151). Don’t get me wrong. Taylor is still the starter, yet this is no longer a “bell cow” situation. McGowan received a carry on the Colts’ fourth offensive snap of Week 10. It would not surprise me if he’s involved early on once again, and it makes no sense for seventh-round pick’s first touchdown odds to be more than double his teammate’s.
- David Montgomery Rushing Yards Pick for Colts vs. Texans
- Best Jonathan Taylor prop bet for Colts vs. Texans on Thursday 11/19/26
- Best C.J. Stroud prop bet for Texans vs. Colts on Thursday 11/19/26
- Colts vs. Texans Player Prop & Anytime TD Betting Splits for Thursday Night Football
- Best Daniel Jones Prop Bet for Colts vs. Texans on Thursday 11/19/26