A frenetic Tribal Council culminated in two fan favorites going home last week on Survivor 51. In the aftermath, major ripple effects have been sent across the beaches of Fiji. An already chaotic season has gotten another dose of intrigue as we push deeper into the merge.
What’s on tap for our ten remaining castaways? Below, we’ll recap all the twists and turns from Wednesday’s ninth episode, titled “Wilder Than a Cat in a Bathtub,” along with revealing who was voted out.
Survivor 51 Episode 9 Recap
Loose Lips
Devin and Jelly are elated to survive (no pun intended) last week’s bloodbath. They say it couldn’t have gone better, although not getting eight votes might have been a better alternative. Devin states that he’s now aware “everyone” is coming after him. Can he shift that target going forward?
Elsewhere, Cristian thinks he just made the move of the season with his Shot In The Dark. In the process, he managed to save new number one ally Carter and his hidden immunity idol. However, Cristian immediately spills the beans to another ally in Sharonda. It’s a major betrayal of Carter’s trust, and a move that could easily backfire down the road.
Idol Hunt
Now that Devin and Jelly played their idol, a new advantage could be released back onto the beach. Maggie pushes her allies to wake up early in an effort to find the idol.
Devin is one step ahead. Using the parchment and wrapping from Jelly’s old immunity idol, he drops a decoy into the jungle. His hope is that someone will think they’ve struck gold, only to come up empty at Tribal Council.
Launching Towards Reward
This week’s reward challenge is enticing. A schoolyard pick seperates the merge tribe into two different teams. Four players will clear a giant rope before pushing a sled down the track. The castaway on top of the sled will untie and grab a key, which they’ll later use to unlock heavy sandbags. Once the bags are released, players will launch the sandbags via slingshot.
The first team to take down three targets will earn a reward. It’s one worth playing for, too: a Fijian helicopter ride leading to a private beach. Awaiting the winners will be a massive fried chicken feast.
Our two teams are neck and neck heading into the final portion of the challenge. It’s Carter and Lewis operating the slingshots, with the latter ultimately coming out on top. it’s Eric, Devin, Lewis, Mike and Thien An that come out on top.
Lewis On the Rocks…
Cristian seems to be playing both sides at the moment, all while battling some serious fatigue. He suggests to Sharonda that they take out Lewis, someone that’s proven to be a physical and social threat. Jelly is in agreement, potentially creating a common ‘enemy’ going into Episode 9’s Tribal Council.
Jelly keeps pushing for Lewis, bringing up his name to Eric on the hammock. He’s intrigued, all while realizing that he’s one of the players operating from the middle. It’s an advantageous spot for Eric, especially at this late stage of the game.
Devin’s Plan Goes Wrong
Jelly wasn’t willing to pigeonhole herself onto just one target. Maggie might make more sense, given her reputation as a strategic threat. Jelly pitches the idea to both Devin and Mike, and both guys seem receptive to the idea.
Devin thinks this so much that he goes out of his way to lead Maggie towards his fake idol. However, she doesn’t see the idol he literally points out to her. That forces Devin to grab his own fake idol, opening it up in front of Maggie. He tells her to hold it, which she refuses.
This is a massive backfire for Devin, on multiple levels. He’s stuck holding onto an ‘idol’ that has absolutely no power. Even worse, someone he’s actively trying to eliminate knows of his faux-advantage. It remains to be seen if Maggie will reveal the news to anyone else on the merge tribe.
A Painful Immunity Challenge
Today’s challenge is fairly straightforward. Players will hold themselves onto a plank overlooking the water. Castaways will need to keep lowering themselves down a peg as the day drags on, at Jeff’s discretion. Making things more difficult, the space to hold onto each peg gets smaller as players move down. The last person to hold on and avoid slipping into the water will win an individual immunity idol.
After a brutal first few minutes, we reach an excruciating final stage of the challenge. It’s Carter, Lewis and Mike left to fight it out after 20 minutes. Mike is quick to go next, leaving the first two guys in a battle of perseverance. Lewis can’t quite hang on, guaranteeing Carter’s spot in the final nine of Survivor 51.
Lewis Scrambles
Sharonda seems set on getting out Lewis, especially after this week’s impressive immunity challenge performance. He’s also a bit of a wildcard, someone the rest of this Survivor cast can’t always predict.
Meanwhile, Carter lets Maggie know that Lewis’ name is being mentioned. She’s more keen on getting out Jelly, someone she sees as a much bigger threat. Thien An agrees, since Jelly never really makes an effort to strategize with her.
Cristian is trying to convince Carter that sending Lewis home is the right move. Carter isn’t so sure; if the Irishman goes home, he might be the next one out the door.
Lewis isn’t blind. He’s aware that his name is being thrown out, and decides to confront Devin about it. The actor unleashes his patented “weaponized honesty,” telling Lewis he’s voting for him unless there’s a better option. In comparison, Eric doesn’t give him much to work with. Lewis continues to plug away, hoping to force another tied vote during Tribal Council.
Coin Flip Chaos
Lewis comes out swinging at Tribal Council, revealing to everyone else that Devin admitted he was this week’s target. It’s sure to draw a few raised eyebrows, from both allies and adversaries alike.
Tribal Council unveils one more massive twist: the coin flip. For those who didn’t watch Survivor 50’s Mr. Beast-inspired twist, someone that successfully flips a coin on the right side doubles this season’s prize money and earns an immunity idol. Lewis is a clear candidate to make a big move, but he’s not the only one. Devin isn’t shy about admitting that he’s itching for a shot at the 50/50 flip. Cristian, following last week’s Shot In The Dark, thinks he might need to push his luck.
After a brief talk, Cristian decides to let Devin flip the coin instead. Lewis is a bit more cautious, since his name is on the block. The two can’t seem to come to a decision, with Lewis going back and forth. Devin ultimately decides not to interfere, giving the opportunity to Lewis instead of himself.
Lewis calls the ‘fire’ side of the coin, but it comes up ‘water’. As a result, he becomes the latest member of Survivor 51 to get their torch snuffed.
Who Was Voted Off Survivor Tonight in Episode 9: Wilder Than a Cat in a Bathtub?
Lewis was sent home via coin flip on Survivor 51 Episode 9: Wilder Than a Cat in a Bathtub.
Survivor 51 Episode 9 FAQ
Who was voted out in Survivor 51 Episode 9?
Lewis was sent home via coin flip on Survivor 51 Episode 9: Wilder Than a Cat in a Bathtub.
When does Survivor 51 Episode 10 come out?
Episode 10 of Survivor 51 will air Wednesday, November 25th at 8 p.m. ET on CBS.
Where to stream Survivor 51?
Survivor 51 episodes can be streamed on Paramount+ the day after they air on CBS.