Adonai Mitchell was supposed to be the third option in this passing game, and through two weeks he leads the Jets in targets. He drew 12 looks against Green Bay after seeing just three in the opener, and now New York heads to Detroit to face a secondary that has been carved up through the air while playing without both of its starting safeties. This is the spot where a big-bodied deep threat gets his chance. Find out whether you should start or sit Adonai Mitchell in Week 3.
Adonai Mitchell Start or Sit Advice for Week 3
Mitchell has 15 targets to Garrett Wilson’s 14, a 25.4% share of New York’s looks, and he has accounted for 44.1% of the team’s air yards. That last number is the one that matters here. Geno Smith is not throwing him screens and hitches; Mitchell is running down the field, and he has nine catches for 123 yards at 13.7 per reception to show for it. The trajectory is what sells it, because three targets to 12 in consecutive weeks is not a rotation, it is a promotion.
Detroit is the defense you want to attack that way. The Lions have surrendered more receiving yardage and more air yards to opposing wide receivers than any other team, 218.5 and 167.5 per game, along with 15 catches per game and a 73.2% catch rate against a league mark of 63.2%. There is an honest caveat attached: they drew New Orleans and Buffalo, two offenses throwing for roughly 38% more than the league average, so some of that damage is a function of who they played rather than how they played.
The structural problem is real, though, and it explains why the schedule excuse only goes so far. Brian Branch and Kerby Joseph, both starting safeties, are on IR and unavailable until Week 5 at the earliest. Detroit is playing with backups at the position responsible for policing vertical routes. Chris Olave went for 10 catches and 182 yards on 149 air yards against them in the opener, which is the precise blueprint Mitchell’s game follows.
Two smaller things break his way. Omar Cooper Jr. and Arian Smith are both on IR, so the receiver room behind Mitchell and Wilson has thinned out and there is no obvious candidate to eat into his snaps. And Detroit’s offense is humming at 24.0 points and 246.5 passing yards per game, which should force the Jets into throwing volume even if they would prefer to grind it out.
The Biggest Fantasy Risk for Adonai Mitchell in Week 3
He has not been targeted in the red zone once. Fifteen looks, zero inside the 20, while Wilson and even Isaiah Williams have each drawn one. Mitchell’s entire scoring path runs through connecting on a long ball, and the Lions have allowed just two red zone targets to receivers all season, so this is not a matchup where he backs into a short touchdown. If the deep throws fall incomplete, his floor is thin.
The hands are the second issue, and they showed up last week. Mitchell caught six of 12 against Green Bay with two drops, dropping his catch rate to 60.0% on the season. That is a lot of volume converted into a modest 63 yards. A 12-target day producing single-digit fantasy points is a live outcome for a receiver who wins downfield but does not always finish the play.
Worth stating plainly: this is a two-game sample on both sides. Mitchell’s target surge came in one game, and Detroit’s numbers allowed came against two of the better passing attacks in football. Neither figure is settled.
Fantasy Outlook for Adonai Mitchell in Week 3
Mitchell is a Strong Start in Week 3 and belongs in lineups as a WR2 with real ceiling. The usage has arrived, the air yards say New York is using him the way his skill set demands, and he is walking into a secondary missing both starting safeties that has already been beaten over the top. Accept that the floor is shaky given the drops and the absence of red zone work, but the version of this game where he catches four of eight for 95 yards and a long score is very much on the table. Start him and live with the variance.
Find more Week 3 fantasy football start/sit coverage here!