Thanksgiving night is really the second screen to the real story: Joe Burrow’s return has turned into appointment news. We went from “out three months after Grade 3 turf toe surgery” in late September to “activated off IR and trending toward starting” headlines in November, with every practice clip getting slowed down and dissected. Beat reports have shifted from “could he make it back this year?” to “how many full sessions does he stack before Baltimore?” and that drift matters for trust. Fantasy managers have held him through dead roster spots, trade deadlines, and waiver crunches specifically for this window. Now the push notification finally hits—Burrow expected to go on Thanksgiving in Baltimore—and you’re staring at your QB slot wondering if the comeback is a gift or a trap.
Below, I break down what Burrow’s first start back from IR against the Ravens on Thanksgiving should look like with Higgins out.
Follow my handle @dansby_edits for more fantasy football advice, as well as plenty of NFL and college football betting goodies.
The stats
The 2025 sample is brutally thin and brutally honest. In Weeks one and two, Burrow gave you 8.82 and 7.04 fantasy points, just 189 passing yards on 5.3 yards per attempt with two touchdowns and no picks. That is backup-level efficiency, even if some of it traces to rust and conservative early-season play-calling. The deeper splits are a little weird: 58.3% completions overall, but 66.7% when pressured and only 54.2% from a clean pocket, plus a strong third-down line with 72.7% completions and ten conversions on eleven pass attempts. That tells me the processing and “gotta have it” gene still live, even if the down-to-down rhythm never materialized before the toe blew up.
You also get the historical reminder that Burrow tends to land the plane hot. Last November he posted 7.1 yards per attempt and +0.14 EPA per dropback; December jumped to 8.1 yards per attempt, 75.3% completions, +0.17 EPA, and a 55.0% third-down rate with sixteen total touchdowns across five games. That December heater is the version you dream about plugging in as your QB1. It proves he handles heavy pressure and late-season stress, not just perfect pockets. The problem is you are not buying that version straight from the shelf; you are buying it off injury rehab, without any 2025 proof of life beyond those two clunky starts.
The ecosystem around him is good but not clean. Ja’Marr Chase is back after suspension and still profiles as a nuclear WR1, sitting at 19.4 fantasy points per game with recent lines of 38.1, 21.1, and 17.1. That ceiling matters, because Burrow’s true blowups tend to ride Chase’s air-yard avalanches. Andrei Iosivas has at least flashed as a viable secondary piece, with 10.6 points in Week twelve and an 18.0-point spike earlier, showing real field-stretch juice when given volume. The issue is protection. Against New England, this line allowed 15 pressures on 39 dropbacks, a 38.46% pressure rate with time to pressure at 2.57 seconds, and both guards losing too often. Dropping a quarterback coming off major toe surgery behind that interior mess is exactly how you cap his floor and force him into hero-ball ticks before the twitch fully returns.
Matchup against the Ravens on Thanksgiving (Week 13)
Baltimore’s defense is not a death sentence, but it is not a soft landing. A 41.0% pressure rate, seven interceptions, forty-four passes defended, and -0.04 EPA allowed per rush describe a unit that stops the run, heats the pocket, and lets its secondary break on rushed throws. EPA allowed per pass sitting at +0.15 says they are more “opportunistic” than “suffocating,” but that is almost worse for a first-game-back scenario: you get volume, but you also get turnover landmines if timing is half a beat off. In a short week with Burrow just ramping up, I do not expect designed runs or scramble aggression to bail you out either.
So what do you actually do in fantasy? His rest-of-season projection at 17.2 points per game screams mid-tier QB1 on paper, but projections assume health and normal variance, not a three-month layoff and a line leaking inside pressure. Jordan Love around 17.9 and Tyler Shough around 16.9 give you similar median outcomes with fewer unknowns and fully intact legs. If you are in a standard twelve-team 1QB league and you have one of those guys or any healthy top-twelve option, I am not forcing Burrow into the lineup just because it is Thanksgiving and the narrative feels rich.
My stance: in typical 1QB redraft, Burrow grades as a high-end QB2 and volatile streamer this week, not a set-and-forget QB1. If you are a projected underdog and need a ceiling play, you can roll the dice on the Chase-fueled eruption and live with the downside. In superflex, you obviously start him everywhere. But if your choice is Burrow versus a healthy, functioning mid-tier starter, I could see waiting one week for proof before I hitch my playoff push to his first steps back.
Me? I’m firing him up. I think you should too.
