The NHL returns with a nine-game slate on Tuesday night, with first puck drop set for 7:00 p.m. ET. The Blue Jackets played last night, and are the only team operating on zero days’ rest.
Here are my favorite three NHL player prop bets on DraftKings Sportsbook for Tuesday, November 11.
Best NHL props for Tuesday 11/11/25
David Pastrnak 4+ Shots on Goal (-125)
Pastrnak has averaged 3.8 shots on goal when playing at home this season and has found plenty of success against the Maple Leafs in previous meetings. He has cleared this line in nine straight meetings, including the past four games played at TD Garden. The Maple Leafs have allowed the fifth-most shots per game and third-most to opposing wingers this season. Pastrnak just totaled 7 SOG on Nov. 8 against Toronto, and he has been even more consistent when playing at home.
Cole Caufield Anytime Goalscorer (+160)
The 24-year-old winger has recorded five two-goal games across the Canadiens’ first 15 games of the season. Seven of his 12 goals have come when playing at home, and Darcy Kuemper is expected to start for the Kings on Tuesday night. Kuemper started off a bit slow but is coming off back-to-back wins, and he ranks fifth in goals saved above expected and 10th in SV% above expected. Montreal’s high-flying offense will be a true test for Kuemper and the Kings, however. The club ranks fifth in 5v5 goals per 60, and Caufield ranks fifth in goals per 60.
Nathan MacKinnon 2+ Points (-115)
MacKinnon has nine (!) points in his last two games, and draws a matchup on Tuesday night against a club he has terrorized in the past, the Ducks. Anaheim is a completely different team in 2025; however, the club is 9-1-0 in its last 10 games and riding a seven-game winning streak entering tonight’s tilt. While Lukas Dostal is 8-3-1 with a 2.66 GAA and .908 SV% this season, he has struggled against MacKinnon and the Avs in the past. Across four career meetings, he sports a 4.89 GAA and .873 SV%. In those four meetings, MacKinnon totaled three goals and four assists.
